Saturday, December 19, 2009

Chocolate Chip PB Cup Cookies

With only 2 ingredients, Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Cups are a favorite treat in our house!

Hello, fellow female. I'm glad we can ignore the boys and make cookies together today. They are too busy playing video games to even notice that this recipe makes almost 3 dozen cookie cups.

Between you and me, we'll just tell them that it only makes one dozen.

Ready to see the magical duo?

One tube chocolate chip cookie dough. One bag mini peanut butter cup candy.

(Or homemade if you have more time on your hands than I do.)

Divvy up the doughy goodness into greased mini muffin pans.

Resist the urge to eat the raw dough. It is bad for you!

Or so "they" say.

Personally, I like to live on the edge.

Bake in 350 degree oven until nice and golden. For us, that takes 11 minutes and 23 seconds.

While you are waiting on the cookies to bake, unwrap one bag of mini peanut butter cups. We throw budget out the window and go for the big dog of pb cups-- it's Reese's, baby!

If you waited until 11 minutes and 24 seconds to remove the cookies from the oven, fret not. All is not lost.

Just don't let it happen again.

You have to listen very very closely to this part. Remove the cookies from the oven and IMMEDIATELY(!!!) push a pb cup right in the middle of the hot cookies!

(If you are doing this with your kidlets, be careful with the hot pans.)

Let the cookies cool completely before removing. Since I have waited long enough by this step, I like to throw the pans in the freezer to move things along more quickly.

(Do you recognize this pic from Thanksgiving? When my helper and I made them this time around, we ate them all up before I realized that I didn't take a pic! No biggie. Except for my gut anyway.)


11 oz bag mini peanut butter cup candy (unwrapped)
16.5 oz tube of chocolate chip cookie dough

YIELD: 33 cookie cups
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
  2. Grease the bottoms of 3 mini muffin tins (a total of 3 dozen cups).
  3. Fill each cup to 2/3 full with cookie dough.
  4. Bake for approximately 11 minutes, or until cookies are done.
  5. Remove from oven and immediately push one peanut butter cup into the center of each cookie.
  6. Cool completely before removing from pan.
  7. Eat up before everyone else figures out they are done!


Miss Rachel said...

yum yum.

Pajama Mama said...

Right back at ya, hot mama! Thanks for the birthday wishes! Your comment made me smile. :)

As for your cookie recipe, these look SO good! But I hold you responsible when I make these cookies and end up with five unwanted pounds because they are so delicious that I eat every last one them!

Have a great weekend!

Duckygirl said...

mmm, those look easy and YUM-MY! :)

NCMom said...

Yummy! I can't wait to try those. My mouth is watering.

Anonymous said...

Ok Marsha, those are ridiculously easy! Always a plus for a homeschooling mom, right? You know, I've seen these delicious little cookies at parties and ballet gatherings and thought how the heck do I make those. Now I know! Thanks!

Molly (:

Hannah said...

Oh yum! Those are the dangerous ones. You know, the ones that are so incredibly delicious and easy to make? Yeah. I'll have to try those sometime!

Sisterlisa said...

My mother-in-law makes those too. A yummy treat! Did you come see my puppy yet???

Alison said...

Huh- you make it look so easy! I don't suppose you know how many grams of fiber would be in those things? protein? vitamin C? :-D
My Dad would say they ARE vitamin C, you know vitamin cookie, of course, this is a man that calls jolly ranchers vitamin C as well, you know, vitamin candy! which, of course, is one of the most essential vitamins...

Anonymous said...

Kevin loves this idea...I might have to try it. :)